Bobby
Jones: A Stroke of Genius (2004)
cast: Jeremy Northam, James
Caviezel, Claire Forlani
Our rating:
3 out of 5
Rated: PG
reviewed by Charity Bishop
Golf in our family is something of a norm. My brother likes to spend long hours
in the backyard practicing his swing. The one time I tried it, I succeeded in
knocking the tee several feet, rolled the ball into the nearby bushes, and took
out a big chunk of our lawn. And that was the third try. Golf is not my forte,
which may be why I was absolutely bored out of my mind by this film.
Little Bobby Jones (Devon Gearhart) is the cutest thing in shoe leather. Beset
with his arrogant little cap and a set of child-sized clubs, he follows his
businessman father around the family golf course and studies the swings of
daddy's wealthy clients. Along the way he learns two of his mightiest weapons:
how to respond when you miss a shot (by throwing the club to the ground and
hollering profanities), and how to knock that ball across the beautiful green
with great ease. The exercise benefits his weak limbs and makes him stronger.
Very rapidly the child earns the admiration of everyone around him, and makes
his way toward becoming a champion. At twelve, he goes up against men twice his
age and beats them royally. He also peaks the interest of journalist O.B. Keeler
(Malcolm McDowell), who professes that this mini-professional has a long career
ahead of him on the green.
As an adult Bobby Jones (Caviezel) is known throughout the world. He's
average as far as the scoreboard goes, but is a public favorite. There's
something about the home-boy style of this champion that appeals to the
masses. Soon he is pitted against the best golfers in the world, including
arrogant "Sir" Walter Hagen (Northam), who gives him a thorough trouncing
because, as he puts it, "You play golf because you love it. I play for
the money, which means I always win." Humiliated by this experience, and
also facing the consequences of his abominable temper, which has lost the
respect of most of the courses, Bobby becomes enraptured with beautiful Mary
(Forlani). She's of aristocratic Catholic stock and has never played golf in
her life, which is perhaps what makes them perfect for one another. But when
illness and preoccupation threatens their match made in heaven, this young
couple will have to learn to survive in a world that has other things
besides heavenly turf to think of.
Deep at its heart, Bobby Jones is a reasonably good story about
overcoming odds, but it gives us very few answers. We know nothing of the
illness that assaulted the boy's weak limbs, nor of his ability to make such
incredible shots. The audience feels at times as though they are on the outside
looking in, when we should be inside the character's minds. There's some
excellent acting from all involved, and a very lyrical kind of dry humor that
pops up at the most unexpected moments. Good lessons about never giving up make
an appearance, when Bobby is "beaten" by a track. (He is told by Hagen that it's
the most beautiful track on the world, because taking it on is a challenge.
Bobby ultimately comes to see that the hardest things are the most rewarding in
the end.) Along for the ride is a heavy dose of self-confidence ("You'll become
the greatest golfer in the world when you know that you are"), but religion is
left out completely or demeaned through the presence of crusty
ultra-fundamentalists who harp on abusing the Sabbath.
Bobby's grandfather is a protestant cleric. His wife is a devoted Catholic.
His mother believes in the zodiac, and brings it up several times. He is,
apparently, nothing. There's no sexual content aside from some comments
about Hagen's legendary love affairs, but what is really unfortunate is the
amount of language packed into the first half of the film. Listening to
adults spout off is one thing, but seeing a six year old throw down his club
in a rage and scream "S***fire" and "son of a ***** ..." seems to be pushing
it. This prominent fault aside, I just wasn't able to get into the film. It
might please fans of the sport, but left me yearning to call "Fore!"
|