Hercules
(2005)
Our rating: 2 out of 5
Rated: TVMA
reviewer: Charity
Bishop
The oldest known form of storytelling can be found in legends. The
stories of Achilles, Hercules, and other Greek gods and heroes have been
passed down through the centuries as a monument not only to the
fantasies of old but revelations of truth throughout the ages. Hercules
is one of the better-known tales, but this is not the light-hearted
approach of Disney. This is a torrid, dark tale of triumph against inner
and outer evils.
It is the night of the festival to honor the goddess Hero, when a blood
sacrifice must be made in order to appease her for yet another season.
High Priestess Alcmene (Elizabeth Perkins) offends the gods when she
attempts to kill a half-man, half-woman oracle and removes from him his
sight. As punishment, she is raped by an unknown god in human form
believed to be Zeus. Her husband Amphitryon (Timothy Dalton) does not
believe this, and swears to murder the child if one is born of the
unholy union. The oracle predicts that two sons will be born, but only
one of them will belong to Amphitryon. When the children are born,
Alcmene bears them into the swamps where the Harpies dwell and asks that
the son of Zeus be killed. The creatures refuse to spill his blood, and
all of her attempts to be rid of her son Hercules are thwarted.
A strong and temperamental child, Hercules draws the unwanted attention
of the crown when in a fit of madness, he strikes down his tutor (Sean
Astin) and appears to have killed him. Forced to flee into the mountains
and escape the wrath of punishment, there he dwells until it becomes
known that a two-headed monster is ravaging the city of Thebes. Now a
grown man, Hercules (Paul Telfer) starts off on a destiny that will lead
him to dark places, from the gates of Hades to the favor of a beautiful
wood nymph (Leelee Sobieski). Through it all, his mother looks upon him
with repulsion and prays Hero will bring an end to his life, as an
affront against Zeus, his father and guardian. I must admit that my
knowledge of Hercules is a trifle rusty since it has been many years
since I studied this particular legend, but the film only covers half of
his grand adventures.
There are six trials Hercules must complete in order to atone for his
sins, which involve the unintentional murder of his three sons. Most of
his adversaries will be known to anyone with an interest in mythology,
and it was fascinating to see such creatures as centaurs, harpies,
sphinx, and two-headed dragons come to life. There is even a mention of
the three-headed dog that guards the gates of the underworld. The
special effects range from being extremely poor (the mythical stag of
the wood is very badly animated) to quite good (the harpies are
fantastic!), and the acting follows a similar pattern. There are moments
when it is good enough to forget how bad some of the dialogue is. The
most impressive thing about the production is the costuming. I loved the
light, airy fabrics used for the wood nymphs and the beautiful lace of
the high priestesses.
That being said, there are aspects of the production that are quite
troubling. There is no outright sexual content but implications of it.
Alcmene is set upon in the woods and forced to the ground, where we hear
her cries. Her husband entices her into bed that same night. There is
much debate on rape and whether or not Zeus is responsible. Megara
(Leeanna Walsman) spends the night with Hercules in the wood (nothing
shown) and then accuses him of raping her when she becomes pregnant.
Deianeira (Sobieski) takes advantage of Hercules after he has been
wounded (we see her bare back, and she kisses him) and bears him a son.
Later, when he has learned the truth, the two are shown kissing in bed.
(Only at the end of the film are they married.) Deianeira is shown
bathing in a pool in the woods, and most of her bare back and half of
her breasts are shown from the back in several rather lengthy shots. The
most troubling is when Megara enters her husband's bedchamber and finds
Hercules' twin brother lying there with him.
Violence is standard for a film of this genre: many men are shot with
arrows. A multi-headed monster attempts to drown the king. Every time
one of its heads is cut off, two more grow in its place, but that
doesn't prevent us from seeing the CGI creature being sliced and diced.
A man is graphically impaled. Three children are taught the ways of
murder in order to kill their father; awakening and believing them to be
demons, he kills them all. Hercules uses a sphinx's own claws to slit
the creature's throat. Men are used as pagan sacrifices to the goddess
Hero, which leads to another problem. In mythology, you cannot take
anything too seriously, but this one treads on the darker side of
paganism. Blood is poured over the severed heads of harpies to awaken
them and glean their wisdom. Priestesses murder a chosen man each year
to appease their goddess. Hercules cries out to all the gods in a vow to
remain loyal to all of them.
There were moments when I truly enjoyed it, because I am fascinated with
ancient Greece and Rome and their cultures and mythologies, but to be
honest the excessively dark tone of the production, the blood
sacrifices, and the homosexual element, however brief, troubled me. More
disconcerting is the belief of the actors involved in the project
(through interviews on the disk) is that they seem to feel this is an
appropriate fantasy for children. Not any children I happen to know!
Note: The film currently out on DVD runs at two hours and ten
minutes in length, but the original miniseries which seems only to run
on television and is available in the UK, is twice as long. This review
covers only the shortened American version.
|