It's
a sorry day indeed when I find myself disliking a Tim Allen
comedy. He's become something of a legend in our household; the
family eagerly embraces many of his films as the very height of
comic relief with occasional moments of romance and friendship
thrown in for good measure. I was hoping Joe Somebody would
follow in the glorious tradition of Galaxy
Quest -- a laugh a minute and some cheese on the side.
Unfortunately in Joe the actual laughs are few, the anatomical
references are many, and there's not enough redeeming value in the
characters to justify the flaws.
Joe
Scheffer (Tim Allen) is the kind of guy everyone ignores. He's
nerdy, smart, and regularly gets stepped on by his coworkers. No
one takes him or his deadlines seriously, he's been passed over
for a promotion several times, and his thespian wife just divorced
him in favor of a spacey New York actor. The one bright spot in
his life is his daughter Natalie (Hayden Panettiere), an aspiring
writer who would rather spend her time crashing at dad's than
enduring the trying ideas of her mother and the most recent
live-in boyfriend. Joe is thrilled, therefore, when Bring Your
Daughter to Work Day arrives. Little does he know the experience
is about to turn into his worst nightmare when a 7-year employee
takes his 10-year employee parking space. Stepping out the car to
politely ask him to move, Joe underestimates the size of the
parking lot bully and is laid flat with a good double-punch to the
jaw.
Humiliated,
Joe ships his daughter off to her mother's and refuses to return
to work. Fearing the ex-employee will sue the company for
'dangerous working conditions,' Joe's jerk boss sends a beautiful
coworker (Julie Brown) to cheer him up. Meg is a long-time
dreamer; she's always wanted to help people overcome their
problems, but is usually sent on these 'pep talk' errands. At
first Joe rejects her offers to make everything right at work, but
then is brought around by one good question she asks him -- what
does he really want? After overcoming the initial hysterics the
question provokes, he comes up with the answer: he wants respect.
He wants... a rematch!
Calling
up the expended coworker who humiliated him in front of everyone,
Joe issues the challenge. In three weeks, when Mr. Jerk returns to
work, they'll duke it out in the parking lot. Suddenly he's a celebrity;
everyone at the company loves him. He's privileged to spend time
with the high-class employees playing squash and attending elite
parties. But in the meantime, both Meg and his daughter think the
rematch is a bad idea, even with his Kung-Fu lessons in self
defense from a washed up Martial Arts movie actor. In this
respect, Joe Somebody does have a little going for it. Mark
eventually realizes it's not always worth fighting about; some
things are worth it, others aren't. A parking space isn't. In the
meantime he develops self-confidence and comes to realize true
friends are the ones who love you even when you're down, not
buttering you up when you're famous. He actually learns a lot from
both his daughter and Meg.
Unfortunately
the rest of the movie falls flat. The acting is pretty good but
the comedy promised rarely surfaces. I think I laughed about five
times in the entire two hours, but then I've reached a point where
I don't find cheap slapstick stunts to be particularly funny,
especially when they deal with body parts. Several times men are
kicked in the crotch; conversation centers around it, along with
crude street slang. (Seeing Tim Allen straddle an ice pack after
his first Kung-Fu lesson was moderately funny; when they rehashed
the joke later, it wasn't.) There's also an abundance of alcohol;
Joe drinks out his sorrows, shares a beer with Meg on their single
date, and attends bars with friends. Violence is mostly slapstick
except for the emotionally devastating scene when a middle-aged
father is socked in the jaw in front of his kid.
Language
is unfortunately high -- way too high to recommend this for family
viewing. I lost count of the number of times "kick his
a**" was thrown around; there are also numerous minor amounts
of deity, profanity by a twelve year old, anatomical slang, and
one abuse each of Christ and Jesus. There isn't any outright
sexual content but it does come up in conversation a few times.
Meg's boss is obviously interested in her romantically and when he
fails to get her attention, calls her a tramp behind her back. He
makes a farce that they slept together, which they didn't. Meg
remarks that even if he tied her to a bed, she'd set herself on
fire before sleeping with him. He also makes one particularly
nasty insult and is punched for it by Joe in return. (The one
instance I was rooting for him to be violent.)
Joe's ex wife is
often shown necking with her boyfriend; after
"actor-boy" leaves, she feels lonely and tries to take
her daughter's keys to Joe's apartment, with the intention of
seducing him. (She's shown briefly in a teddy.) Natalie talks her
out of it, saying she has no right to "run over his
heart" a second time. In addition, Joe's daughter is sweet
but also rude to her father, even when she's right. I
simply cannot recommend this film for all its flaws. There is a
bright spark at the end, but the experience was ultimately
unsatisfying.