Law
& Order, Season Four
Our rating: 3 out of 5
Rated: TVPG
reviewed by
Charity Bishop
Law & Order continued pulling no punches on
primetime with the introduction of new characters into
the crime drama that already had and audiences talking.
With its "ripped from the headlines" cases and
occasional perusal of the characters' personal lives, it
entered into one of the most compelling seasons.
When a convicted pedophile is shot and killed on a controversial talk
show, Detectives Lennie Briscoe (Jerry Orbach) and Mike Logan (Chris
Noth) are convinced there's more to the fatal shooting than an angry
father gone haywire. Their investigation winds up on the doorstep of the
talk show host, known for his morally ambivalent and often cruel
tactics, but District Attorney Adam Schiff (Stephen Hill) is reluctant
to prosecute such a well-known television personality. His executive
chief prosecutor Ben Stone (Michael Moriarty) believes the shooter has
evidence that can help them convict, but the shooter is reluctant to
involve his abused son in the investigation. Together with his new
assistant Claire Kincaid (Jill Hennessy), Stone pulls no punches in
order to bring this ego-inflated showman to trial.
With the transferal of Donald Cragan to another department, the new head
cop in the precinct is Anita Van Buren (S. Epatha Merkerson). Strong,
tough, and personable, occasionally she butts heads with her ambitious,
logic-driven male detectives. Ben and Claire also run into a few violent
disagreements and mishaps along the lonely road that leads to justice,
but inevitably all cases are brought to the court, whether they involve
extortion and kidnapping or harassment and blackmail. From corrupt
judges to religious fanatics, each intense episode features an host of
fascinating plot twists and criminal cases that get us into the legal
minds of the justice system. If you ever thought being a cop was easy,
think again. And if you ever assumed you get to hear all the evidence at
trial, you're wrong.
One of the more valued aspects of the series, beyond its
conversation-starters about American justice and morality in the system,
is its surprisingly accurate view into the life of a New York City
police detective, and the Prosecutor that often has to take very little
evidence to trial. There are appeals and bench warnings, arrest warrants
and evidence thrown out because of inappropriate police action. There
are the politics involved and occasional clashing of interests. The
criminals they are hesitant to prosecute due to their power and
prestige, the low-life's they give deals to in order to catch much
bigger fish. It's good stuff and the introduction finally of such
television personalities as Claire Kincaid and Anita Van Buren brought
an already decent show into its stride, known as the "golden years."
Numerous episodes this season are intense in their depiction of crimes,
but for the most part it's a solid succession of instances to intrigue
the audience. Some cases are related to sexual escapades because, after
all, crime is motivated by greed, revenge, or sex. "Sweeps" talks about
a pedophile in non-graphic terms. "Discord" becomes explicit in its
verbal description and investigation of a rape case (a young woman
accuses a rock star of assaulting her). Numerous cases reference
adulterous affairs. A couple make out passionately before discovering a
body in an alley. "Censure" forces a former adulterous affair of
Claire's to the surface. "Mayhem," a cynical slant on the "day from
hell" in the NYC office, implies a woman has castrated her husband after
learning of his adultery.
"Apocrypha" revolves around a cult leader thrown out of the Christian
church for his subtle claims that he is the messiah. Most of those
involved are cultural Catholics, but it doesn't build a case against
organized religion. Logan claims that due to his abuse at the hands of
his Catholic mother, he'll never enter another church, but crosses
himself poignantly at the end of the episode. In "Sanctuary," a black
minister ignites racial passions when a Jewish hit-and-run driver isn't
prosecuted for his crimes. If I had one complaint it would be this
season's inability to grant explanations. It never tells us where
Captain Cragan went, and gives Anita no defining entrance. Claire
resigns in one episode only to be back at work in the next, without
granting us the opportunity to witness her return. The season also
featured rising tempers between Adam Schiff and Ben Stone, a precursor
for the final episode in which Stone resigns, leaving the door wide open
for season five's introduction of Jack McCoy.
|