Charlotte
Gray (2001)
Our rating: 3 out of 5
Rated: PG13
reviewed by: Charity
Bishop
Cate Blanchett is such a diversifying actress that to see her in anything is to
watch pure poetry in motion. Refusing to allow herself to slide into stereotype,
she always chooses strong, dynamic and influential female roles who leave a
lingering impression. The character of Charlotte Gray is probably her strongest
and most compelling lead since Elizabeth. Set in Nazi-occupied France at
the height of World War II, Charlotte Gray is the story of a young woman
who joins the French Resistance in the hope of locating and rescuing her missing
lover, a RAF pilot.
But what Charlotte finds instead is that there are more important battles to
be fought... and that she cannot trust anyone. Traveling to London for
purposes of her own, Charlotte Gray (Cate Blanchett) is a quirky, beautiful,
and intelligent Scottish girl who speaks French fluently and loves to
read. While on the train she is brought into conversation with a gentleman
who leaves her his card, and an invitation for her to attend a book gala. At
this gala, she makes the acquaintance of Peter Gregory (Rupert
Pentry-Jones), a courageous young British pilot soon to be sent into France
to fight for the resistance. The two share a few brief but memorable weeks
together, and then he is sent to war. After his departure she joins up with
the spy force SOE, which uses women as couriers in Nazi-occupied countries.
When Peters plane goes down somewhere over the communist south of France,
Charlotte asks to be stationed there as a courier. Parachuting down in the
dead of night, she is placed under the care of a French communist by the
name of Julian (Billy Crudup) while she awaits her English contact. On a
trial run, she's assigned to pass off a package to woman in a coffee shop,
but her contact is arrested.
Julian also discovers the Jewish parents of two little boys in his
building have been taken and sent to concentration camps. The children
are taken to the home of his aging father. Charlotte is assigned to the
children's care as housekeeper and nanny, while awaiting further orders.
But she hasn't forgotten about Peter, and makes one last desperate
attempt to locate him. The one vague hope to which she clings may cost
her everything. As a spy thriller, Charlotte Gray moves at a
measured pace and did little to please the critics, despite excellent
performances by Cate Blanchett, Michael Gambon, and Billy Crudup; but as
a WWII era romance and a story of courage, conviction, and
self-sacrifice, it seems palatable. Not perfect, but pleasing to the eye
and with a gripping melodramatic tension. Charlotte is surprisingly
two-dimensional; her grief, horror, and fear is very real. The
characters are all equally charismatic and several scenes gut-wrenching.
The cinematography on this film, along with the haunting music, are
utterly beautiful and captivating.
Content-wise, most of the violence is anticipated and not overly graphic
or gory. Men mowed down by German machine guns (only implied), and one
man is shot at close range. We don't see the actual impact, but blood
sprays onto the face of his female companion and his body falls to the
ground. The murder is perceived justified because of his earlier
actions, attempting to woo a woman against her will and threatening
major characters. Explosions wrack train tracks, derailing the train; a
man whose jacket is caught on fire is seen escaping from the burning
boxcars. A woman is struck in the face with a rifle butt trying to
protect two children from Nazis. Language is mild except for three uses
of the f-word, and one abuse each of Jesus and Christ. Sensitive viewers
should be aware that Jews are seen shipping out in a prison-train,
including central characters. Unfortunately, sex is misunderstood for
love and we see Charlotte and Peter in bed (obviously undressed) shortly
after their first meeting. Julian and Charlotte make out passionately to
distract a guard. A plot twist involves attempted sexual blackmail. One
of the townsmen knows more about Charlotte and her companions than is
wise and implies for favors hell keep quiet. He kisses her passionately
and tries to run his hand up her leg under her skirt before she pulls
away. Its a pity sensuality interrupts a good plot line with a
bittersweet ending.
There's a lot to like about Charlottes character even with her loose sense
of morals. One glimpses the truth found in us all... the future is always
frightening, but that when the occasion presents itself, even the most meek
can find within themselves enough courage to face any situation. I
particularly liked her selfless love for the two Jewish boys and the great
grief she showed over her faults. Not as diverting as most WWII thrillers,
but Charlotte Gray leaves you with something to think about.
|