Doctor
Zhivago (1965)
Our rating: 2 out of 5
Rated: PG13
reviewed by:
Brett Willis
This is a long and complicated story, sometimes seeming disjointed and confusing
for those like myself who've never read the Boris Pasternak novel, but an epic
nevertheless. The story takes place in Russia. The primary time setting is just
before, during and after WWI. But there's a brief glimpse of an earlier time
when young Yuri Zhivago (Tarek Sharif) lost his mother and was taken in by
another family, gaining a new sister, Tonya, in the process. And, the primary
story is bracketed by sequences from apparently the 1940s or 50s in effect, told
in flashback and narrated by Yuris half-brother, Gen. Yevgraf Zhivago (Alec
Guinness), who is searching for the long-lost daughter of Yuri (played as an
adult by Omar Sharif) and his mistress Lara (Julie Christie).
As the primary story opens, Yuri is both a medical doctor and a poet of some
note. Czarist Russia suffers from war with Germany and from political
turmoil within. An anti-Czarist rally is attacked by mounted police who use
their swords to cut down women and children and to put a permanent scar on
the cheek of activist Pasha Antipova (Tom Courtenay). Meantime, Pashas
fiancé Lara is serving as a lover to the rich and slimy Victor Komarovsky
(Rod Steiger), who is also her mothers lover. Eventually Pasha forgives Lara
and they're married. Yuri marries Tonya (Geraldine Chaplin). And Yevgraf is
busy betraying the Russian army from within and helping them to lose
the war, because he believes the additional suffering will usher in the
Bolshevik (Communist) Revolution. And he's correct.
During the Revolution, all hope of a normal life is lost. Anyone who is deemed
an enemy of the State is re-educated or shot. The possessions of the rich are
confiscated. Finding food and shelter is a constant struggle. And men can be
impressed into the army either the White (Czarist) Army or the Red Army with no
warning. This of course includes doctors, who are needed as medical officers.
The violence is intense at times, very sad at others (such as a platoon
of very young boys being cut down by a machine gun); but filmed in the
old style with blood but no splattering. The language is quite clean. I
counted one instance each of b*tch, bastard and slut, and some mild
innuendo. At one point, Yuri and Lara are very attracted to each other
while working together as a doctor and nurse for a period of six months,
but behave themselves. Lara explains she wants them to have no regrets
when he returns to his wife. But later, when they meet in other
circumstances, they finally give in to their passions. The way this is
presented is also in the old style, with the two of them seen together
in bed but with no visible nudity or overt sexual movement. Lara is
still married to Pasha, though he no longer acknowledges her, now calls
himself Strelnikov, and is a ruthless and feared Red Army leader.
Yuri now divides his time between Tonya and Lara. At one point (while Tonya
is pregnant with their second child), he breaks off the relationship with
Lara. But then he's forcibly taken away from contact with both
Lara and Tonya; and when he is able to return its Lara he returns to
and writes famous poetry about. The films overall impact is that their
relationship is nothing to be upset about; in fact, its presented as a loves
sweet agony ideal. The overall mood is one of sadness. Peoples lives forever
changed because of a war with an obscure cause. Needless suffering and
death. Lovers separated from each other. Children separated from their
parents. Not the kind of thing you want to watch just before going to sleep.
And there are no heroes to attach oneself to; all of the main characters are
flawed. Yet, this story represents a real slice of history and as such may
be worthwhile for mature viewers.
|