Mansfield
Park (1999)
Our rating: 3 out of 5
Rated: PG13
reviewed by
Charity Bishop
Young Fanny Price has grown used to being ignored, used,
and kicked around in modern society ever since being sent to live
with her boorish aunt and uncle at Mansfield Park. Her one
conciliation is her cousin Edmund, who manages to liven up many a
dull hour in merriment. The pair are inevitably close friends,
almost as brother and sister from their secrets and poetry readings
to playful banter as they grow older. But one day, everything
changes and a new face is brought to the manor...
Or rather,
two new faces -- the renters of the nearby parsonage
are one Henry Crawford (Alessandro Nivola) and his sister Mary
(Embeth Davidtz). The former is an unabashed playboy while the
latter is in all appearances a fortune hunter and maddening
flirt. Fanny's cousins, Maria and Julia, are both taken with
this extremely good looking new neighbor, despite the fact that
Maria is engaged to a dull but moral Mr. Rushford (Hugh
Bonniville) of the town. Henry does not appose the flirtation
but rather embraces it, for, as he confides to his sister, he
enjoys intrigues with women of unquestionable nature. Edmund
(Jonny Lee Miller) has taken a supreme interest in Mary,
something Fanny (Frances O'Connor) secretly envies.
It is about this time Fanny comes into the knowledge that her
uncle owns many slaves to work his plantations in India and she
expresses some opposition toward the idea. Her relatives find
her opinions appalling... all but Edmund, who believes that a
sound mind is much more important than a pretty face. However,
her shy thankfulness for his support is short lived when her
uncle expresses the idea of a ball to introduce her to society
(beings as she's gotten so "fetching") and hopefully hook her up
with a wealthy young man.
Always below their station in life and having come from a poor
family, she is more frightened of this opportunity than excited
but on the night of the ball finds herself dancing in the arms
of Henry Crawford, who has suddenly taken an interest in her.
Maria (Victoria Hamilton) has been married, taking Julia
(Justine Waddell) away with her on her honeymoon out of fear of
being left entirely alone with her husband, and Fanny is alone
at Mansfield Park... left to bide the attentions of Henry, who
professes a deep and passionate love for her. Her uncle, of
course, is ecstatic at the match with a man of good blood and
and -- more importantly -- wealth. But she
refuses the marriage and in punishment is sent home for a
prolonged visit. Finding her family much changed, Fanny begins
to miss her true home... and Edmund.
She manages to pass the time well in the company of her beloved
sister... until the day Henry appears, determined to persuade
her to marry him. Mansfield Park is a beautiful piece
of filmmaking, exquisitely photographed and delicately edited
with bold, airy rooms and breathtaking British countryside.
However a few imperfections flaw this otherwise worthwhile film.
One is a hint at lesbianism which cannot be overlooked in a
scene between Fanny and Mary in which the former is eager to
help her undress, and makes comments about her figure. This is
entirely of the director's own making, for Jane Austen would be
appalled. Another is a scene in which Fanny intrudes mistakenly
to find Henry in bed with a married Maria. One of Maria's bare
breasts is seen for an instant before she covers herself and
hides her face in his chest. There is also brief flashes of a
sketchbook belonging to Edmund's brother Thomas, who has
protested at his father's use of slaves. In it are tortured
sequences of rape, murder, and abuse. Several glimpses of
women's bare breasts are shown but Fanny flips quickly and the
pictures are only seen for a few seconds. Some mildly suggestive
dialog is spattered here and there and varying amounts of
cleavage are present.
Fanny proves steadfast in her morality, choosing the right
rather than the wrong and is very likable in herself. Edmund has
aspirations to become a pastor and shows maturity and good sense
throughout the film, even as his obsession with Mary progresses.
It's a well put together production with passion in every frame
and witty narration, all from Fanny's point of view. Lovers of
the original novel will be disappointed as it bears little
resemblance to the volume Austen penned, but if you're looking
for a good regency period film and not necessarily thinking
"Jane Austen," this is choice that will probably please. It's a
pity the director felt the need to throw in some smut, for it's
a good story rather reminiscent in places of Jane Eyre
and very easily could have made a PG rating. Keep the fast
forward button handy if you rent this one... or hunt up an
edited copy through a friend. It may not have the innocence of
Emma or Sense & Sensibility, but it is a charming
-- if reluctant --
romance with a good heart.
|