Master
& Commander (2003)
Our rating: 3 out of 5
Rated: PG13
reviewed by
Charity Bishop
Master & Commander: The Far Side of the World is an
exuberant sea adventure that ranks of the intelligence
and believability this year's surprise blockbusters
lacked. It comes with a heavy historical basis, truly
likable although not completely well-defined secondary
characters, and excellent acting by all involved. It
brings together an intriguing tale of a crew pitted
against an unstoppable enemy and the insight,
cleverness, and uniqueness which allowed them to
triumph. The storyline does include graphic battles at
sea, more violence than one might anticipate, and leaves
the ending open for a sequel, but is a stunning glimpse
into a bygone era, naval intelligence, and also
illuminates some downright profound virtues.
The year is 1805 and although the British navy still control much of
sea-faring trade, French privateers under the command of Napoleon are
rapidly becoming a problem. They loot and pillage anything under a
British flag. The HMS Surprise under Captain Jack Aubrey (Russell
Crowe) has been commissioned to hunt down and stop the most troublesome
of these, the near-uncatchable Acheron. With 162 souls aboard, he
pursues his quarry and finds instead himself the hunted, when Acheron
time and again manages to catch him unawares. The story does not merely
center around his struggle with pride and determination, but also
follows the life of his close friend Dr. Maturin (Paul Bettany), an
intellectual and budding naturalist. It's an ironic pairing... a man of
science, and one of war. Their differences collide often, resulting in
the growth of each character and eventually working together to obtain
their ultimate goal.
The
HMS Surprise is nearly sunk in the fog one bitter morning when she comes
upon the privateer with little warning. Forced to list for repairs, Aubrey
is determined to hunt down their quarry and see her taken or sunk. One of
his crewmen was familiar with the Acheron's building process while
she was still in the Colonies, and informs him why their cannons were unable
to penetrate her hull: it's been triple-sided, giving them almost a foot of
solid oak. Her only weakness is from behind, and the gun-ports. They would
have to be nearly on top of her in order to successfully take her captive,
and this proves extremely dangerous as they would be blown to smithereens in
the process. Maturin encourages him to give up the quest as he's fulfilled
his promise to track her thus far, but Aubrey's honor is at stake. Despite
the feelings of the crew, he is determined to bring this hound to heel...
little knowing he is not the hunter, but the hunted. This allows for some
brilliant strategy as our enterprising crew find ways to keep alive in
wartime.
That's not to say men aren't lost by battle or fierce weather; there's
nothing good-natured about this sea-faring journey, which begins in utter
seriousness and concludes on a similar note. This is hard-core navy life
during the early eighteen hundreds, complete with rotting bread,
seasickness, the bloody aftermath of battle, and dealing with guilt.
Fortunately interspaced between the intense scenes of warfare are touching
moments between captain and crew, and some truly soul-seeking conversations.
Maturin accuses the captain of going after the Acheron
merely out of an egotistic desire to avenge himself. Angrily, Aubrey
denies it... but realizes later he was in the wrong and takes steps to
release his wrath and work instead for the good of his men. This philosophy
is shown numerous times, as individuals are sacrificed for the common good.
Each time the audience is hit with the emotional impact of forcing to make
such a choice.
There are many scenes of intense, violent combat, often with bloody
results. Ships are blown apart by cannon fire, resulting in the loss of
life. Bloodied bodies are seen strewn across the decks, and going under
the doctor's knife. A little boy must have his arm amputated. A bullet
must be removed from a man's brain, and the camera and crew gawk
throughout the semi-gory process. We observe a self-operation with the
use of a mirror, which sometimes proves bloody and disturbing. Many men
are shot and killed in the final battle scene, or stabbed with sabers.
The violence is all close-range, largely out of focus (which is
extremely irritating in close-ups), and flashes rapidly past in an
effort to maintain the PG13 rating while still giving paying customers a
glimpse of the gritty warfare they came to see. Language also intrudes
but is primarily British slang (the term "bloody") and mild abuses of
profanity. There are numerous mild abuses of deity, but one f-word
(unhistorical since it wasn't often voiced at this period) and a GD
creep into the dialogue.
Other than the extreme violence, the film has little by way of offensive
content. There is no sexual escapades or even hints of impropriety aside
from an off the cuff remark (in response to a toast "to wives and
sweethearts," the captain jokingly ads "May they never meet") and a
background instruction for a sailor to put down a woman, since "this is a
sailing ship, not a bordello!" For the most part all references to God are
made with respect and burials at sea carry a distinctively religious
overtone. There is one brief implication of the possibility of evolution by
the doctor/naturalist. Most war films lack empathy, but Master &
Commander takes you on an emotional journey, which is what sets it
apart. Little boys taking charge of guns, being forced to contend with
amputations, and yet clinging to their literary heroes. The usual
superstition which was rampant among seaman at the time. Order and obedience
among the crew, even if it means tying a man to the mast and giving him
twenty lashes for insolence. Liberals will not like this film for a variety
of reasons, primarily that it encourages patriotism, taking personal
responsibility, and has an anti-pacifist worldview. These are not monsters
but men, and the quiet moments when they all deal with guilt, fear, anger,
and sorrow are profoundly revealing. For older audiences, this can be an
excellent conversation-starter, but leave the kids at home.
|