Middlemarch
Our rating: 4 out of 5
Rated: PG
reviewed by Charity Bishop
Although not my favorite adaptation of a George Elliot novel (that honor
belongs to Daniel Deronda), MiddleMarch is a fascinating
glimpse into the small town lives of various young people caught up in
the impossible expectations of others. The series cannot be classified
in a single sentence, but mostly it is about shattering preconceptions
and learning to find a way through adversity.
Most of the story centers around the intelligent and ambitious Dorthea
(Juliet Aubrey), who longs to be of some use in the world, who has no
interest in wearing jewels simply because she owns them, and hopes to
put her book learning to good use. She is quiet and sensible where her
sister is more flirtatious and fun loving, and it comes as no surprise
when the local Reverend Casaubon (Patrick Malahide) decides that she
will make him an able wife and companion. Her liking for him, and her
hopes that together they can make great cultural advancement through his
studies, encourages her to accept his offer of marriage, but Casaubon
seems more interested in his research than he does his wife, leaving her
on her honeymoon to wander the streets of Rome alone. There, she chances
to meet his spirited cousin Ladislow (Rufus Sewell), the proverbial
black sheep of the family and an aspiring artist with no great
ambitions.
While Casaubon remains distant from his cousin, Dorthea strives to
improve her marriage and make herself useful. In the meantime, the small
country town of Middlemarch where she grew up has seen the introduction
of a new physician. Dr. Lydgate (Douglas Hodge) does not take long to
settle himself among the inhabitants of the town, or to find new
patients. He even has no true interest in marriage... until he meets and
falls in love with the beautiful Rosamond (Trevyn McDowell), who seems
not to realize that a small country doctor should live within his means.
Then there is the son of a local landowner, Fred Vincy (Jonathan Firth),
who wants nothing more than the hand of his favorite young woman in
marriage, but Mary (Rachel Power) will not have him unless he finds an
actual profession and stops gambling away his life savings.
The result is an astoundingly complicated miniseries with so many minor
characters that you really do have to see it more than once in order to
follow all of the storylines. I found it somewhat tedious in places and
it seemed that the series would have profited from being condensed even
more in order to highlight the six main characters more than the slew of
townspeople that surround them. Even so, these plot points served an
ultimate purpose in determining where various characters wound up, so I
cannot complain too heartily. The production value is quite good even
though the transfer onto DVD has caused some players to distort the
image. (I did not have that problem, but several of my friends did.) It
is quite atmospheric but sometimes the characters behave so badly that
you want to slap some common sense into them.
Problematic content is limited to a dozen or so mild profanities and
some marital flirtations, passionate kissing, and the like. Dr. Lydgate
helps his wife undress on one occasion and they have rather a steamy
kissing scene together. Dorthea suspects a married woman is involved
with a man other than her husband; the woman admits that she considered
it, but the man would not behave so dishonorably. There are some moral
calamities and the presence of gambling, but overall it is a tame
experience that should suit most costume drama fans just fine, so long
as they remember to pay close attention, less they miss some of the
faces involved in the entwining plot lines.