Napoleon
(2002)
Our rating: 3 out of 5
Rated: TV14
reviewed by Charity Bishop
One of the most infamous figures in foreign history was Napoleon
Bonaparte, the French dictator who came to power through
successful war victories and his influence among the people.
A&E, who is known for their epics, brings us an enthralling look
into the personal life, public battles, and empathetic struggles
behind the infamous name. In doing so, they make Bonaparte a
little more forgivable for his actions and help us understand
how such a little man could pack such a mighty political wallop.
The story begins on the island of his confinement after
Bonaparte's expulsion from France by his British enemies. The
small man of large stature refuses admission to any of English
alliance and keeps much to himself in his shame. Fading into
history, we are introduced to a newly-restored Paris. The
monarchy has come to an end, replaced by the People's Republic
of France. The country has been brought to near bankruptcy by
the costly and systematic execution of former public officials,
rioting in the streets, and the escaped aristocracy. Napoleon
Bonaparte (Christian Clavier) is a little-known figure within
the Republic, a man whose only desire is to marry the beautiful
Josephine (Isabella Rossellini), the mother of two nearly-grown
children and a woman of romantic reputation.
His mother is adversely against the marriage, advising it would
be imprudent of him to link their noble family blood with "such
a woman." But Bonaparte is resolved, and after a successful
ambush and slaughter of revolting peasants in the city square,
is appointed to a higher military position and able to marry.
From here the story progresses into war, as he is called to
secure the borders of France and strengthen their military
presence. This requires his departure from home over long
periods of time, in which he fears his wife will go astray. Her
letters do not come with as much passion or urgency as he would
have hoped. His unannounced return finds a former lover flying
from the house; but Josephine persuades him all is well and she
is merely trying to pursue his political agenda.
Pressures are coming from all sides, particularly toward his wife. Into his
confidence are taken Joseph Fouché (Gérard Depardieu), the current prefect
of police, whose loyalty is demanded rather than invited. His brutality and
cold-hearted manner of dealing with infidels proves him a heartless member
of Bonaparte's rising team of politicians, but also gives way to some
excellent insights into Parisian life... and the many plots undertaken by
former Loyalists to restore the monarchy to the throne. Also with a hand in
the batter is Talleyrand (an ever-droll John Malkovich), a cripple with a
criminal mind for detail and a great deal of influence among the upper
class. This propagandist, as well as many other voices of reason, encourage
Bonaparte to divorce Josephine and marry someone who might produce him with
an heir.
For a time he remains resolute and faithful to his wife, but
time and history will form the makings of a much greater, more
domineering and powerful man than the general whose expertise
make such a dynamic example of military strategy on the
battlefield. While being entertaining, A&E's adaptation of the
classic novel by Max Gallo does incredible justice to the times,
workings, and life of one of history's most fascinating
characters. The beady-eyed Christian Clavier was born to play
the role; his Bonaparte is both interesting, empathetic, and
dislikable whether he's courting Josephine, dealing in cold
blood with military threats, or leading his armies on to
victory, he never fails to maintain the facade that he is
Napoleon. The rest of the cast triumph or fall based on
individuality, but his strength carries the production through
from beginning to end.
Anyone with even a remote knowledge of Bonaparte will know the film has two
main hinges: his romantic and battle pursuits, therefore an equal amount of
seduction and violence is expected. A&E delivers but with far more restraint
than I originally anticipated. The battles are all bloody, stretching their
TV rating as far as humanely possible with spurts of blood and slow-action
shots. Carnage lies in the streets after a bomb goes off, killing passerby
and dismembering a cart pulled by a horse. (Nothing gory lingers on screen.)
In a particularly jarring early sequence, Bonaparte orders his men to fire
on revolutionists, slaughtering them in the town square with ruthless
ambition until none are left alive. Things get hideous when his armies are
forced out of Russia due to a bitter winter -- the camera lingers on
frostbitten arms, legs, and noses.
In the first episode sexual content is kept to a minimum but
does exist through dialogue. Women chuckle over the state of a
man's pants, make flirtatious remarks about swimming in the
nude, and entertain passionate letters (the contents of which we
never hear). Intense kissing intrudes on many occasions, along
with dialogue about "making love," producing heirs, and other
sexually-related remarks. In the second disk, however, the story
has progressed into Bonaparte's years of infidelity. Fortunately
we never see anything overly graphic but are forced to endure
his pursuit of young women. Numerous times we see him kissing
women other than his wife, pulling at their corset strings, or
curled up in the arms of a young beauty. It's implied a married
countess (no more than twenty) becomes his mistress after being
convinced he will do something for her homeland of Poland in
return. On a minor note, the costuming for the women is also
very immodest. The low necklines are nothing worse than you
would see in an Austen adaptation, but the filmmakers unusually
chose to make the garments very loose on the actresses, which
results in more dangerous plunges. There is also some mild
language and a scene in which the camera lingers indefinitely on
a very nude baby boy.
I was surprised, considering the nature of some of A&E's equally
controversial conquests that they kept it as modest as they did,
but still Bonaparte's illicit sexual affairs and the nature of
some of the violence will deter many families, including mine,
from viewing this feature intact. For older viewers prepared to
endure a little scandal in a historical context, Napoleon
will prove a fascinating glimpse into one of the greatest
dictators of the age.