Schindler's
List (1993)
Our rating: 3 out of 5
Rated: R
reviewed by Charity Bishop
Something of a reluctant hero to begin with, Oskar Schindler was a German
profiteer during WWII's invasion of Poland. Stephen Spielberg filmed this movie
without salary and despite studio protests in order to pay homage to what
happened to millions of Jews during the Holocaust. The result is a
thought-provoking film horrible in the most personal kind of way. It shows us
blatant cruelty and terror up close yet manages to also convey internal struggle
in the primary characters, who are equally flawed yet intensely charismatic.
It's certainly not for the faint of heart and is like no other movie ever made.
It's not as gruesome as The Passion but that doesn't matter...
Schindler's List will stay with you for a long time.
Nazis have just invaded Poland. Oskar Schindler (Liam
Neeson) is a wealthy German looking for investors to
begin a metal manufacturing plant. He wastes little
time in befriending high ranking German officials,
mostly of a military nature, but goes to the already
oppressed Jews for finances. Among those working in
the local relief office is Itzhak Stern (Ben
Kingsley), an accountant whom Schindler hires to
help get his industry off the ground. Stern brings
together the wealthiest Jews from the Ghetto and
they strike a bargain. They will give him millions
to start the company, and he will pay them back in
tradable items. Money is worth nothing inside Ghetto
walls, but illegal trade is booming. They meet
wherever they can, and those who work outside the
walls have special privileges. Jews have been turned
out of their homes, streets, and synagogues.
Schindler has taken up residence not far from the
Ghetto. He can work Jews cheaply in his factory, and
through military contracts for crockery, hinges, and
other metal necessities, can build a fortune.
Around him, Poland is starting to unravel. He must
rescue Stern from a liquidation train bound for a
gas camp. His workers are removed to shovel snow for
incoming army transports. One of them is shot in the
head simply for being one-armed. Stern seems to be
using his plant as a hideaway for the Jews most
likely to be terminated. Old men, very young
children, those with birth defects. Schindler is
enraged because it slows his money-making industry,
but as the war progresses begins to feel stronger
empathy for his workers. He watches as the Ghetto is
forcefully liquidated. Jews are lined up and shot.
They're herded off into other camps, beneath the
tyrannical, cruel hand of Amon Goeth (an overweight
Ralph Fiennes). He likes to shoot prisoners randomly
from the balcony of his villa overlooking the camp.
He's chosen a young Jewish girl (Embeth Davidtz) to
act as a housemaid; she fears for her life.
Schindler makes a friend of Amon and uses his
influence to bring more empathy to the camps. But
there is an end to what influence he can wield,
particularly when Germany begins to fear it may lose
the war.
Schindler's List is more than merely a brutal
glimpse at the horrors inflicted upon the chosen
race. It's also the story of one man's
transformation from money-hungry businessman to
humanitarian. Schindler begins with very little
empathy or interest in the Jews beyond what finances
they can build for him, but by the end has
sacrificed a great deal to become their liberator.
He doesn't smuggle them out by the hundreds but
instead gives them work in his factories. Because
they're producing military-related items, they are
not so rapidly "liquidated." The ammo shells they
produce are purposefully defective. He gives his
entire fortune to "buy" them from the gas chambers,
and still feels wracking remorse that he couldn't
get "Just one more!" Stern plays a large part in
forcing Schindler's hand. He rapidly erases all
Schindler's preconceived notions toward the German
army. He deliberately places Jews in need of
assistance into the man's way. He acts as his
conscience on many levels. This is the true heart of
the movie, beyond the horrors of seeing children
loaded onto transports and the streets bathed in ash
from the furnaces. The performances are powerful,
the setting is powerful, the story is powerful.
Ralph Fiennes and Liam Neeson were both rightly
nominated for Oscars.
The atmosphere of the film is very dark and moody.
It was filmed in black and white so color would not
detract from performances, but perhaps also to avoid
being too gory on such a personal subject for the
director. If it was in color, the film would be much
more difficult to take. There are numerous scenes
and implications of violence. Men and women are shot
at point-blank range, often spurting blood on the
ground and passerby. Bloodstains eek into the snow
beneath fallen bodies, and bathe the streets.
Soldiers conceal themselves in the Ghetto to await
darkness, when all who have hidden will come out.
Then they rush up to slaughter them -- we hear the
constant fire of machine guns, the reflective light
bouncing off the walls while a single soldier plays
Mozart on a Jewish piano. Nazis choose their victims
randomly. The man without an arm. Every other person
in a lineup. Someone slower, thinner, fatter, or
darker than the others. Amon picks them off from his
balcony. He gives one boy freedom after failing a
task and we see the child dead in the next shot.
Tempted by Helen, his Jewish servant, Amon becomes
angry and beats her. We see him throwing her around
the room, punching her in the face, and finally
overturning a cabinet on her.
Violence is forgivable in this kind of a film, since
in order to get emotional impact you have to show
what it was like -- terrible. But the nudity and
sexual content is gratuitous and could have been
avoided. Schindler was an avid womanizer and
entertains many pretty girls. He's shown engaged in
fairly graphic sex with one of them. The woman is
naked and we see her bare breasts. Another
bare-breasted woman is seen in his room toward the
end of the film. Helen has just come out of a bath
when Amon comes downstairs. You can make out the
outline of her breasts through the partially-sheer
garment she's wearing. While he shoots Jews from his
balcony, one of his many girlfriends lays on the bed
topless. We see her breasts in several shots; in the
same sequence, we see him urinate (no nudity) in the
bathroom. Prisoners are ordered to strip and run
around in a circle so "doctors" can pick out the
worthless ones. There's male and female full nudity
in these scenes, as well as later when the girls are
forced into German "showers." Editing companies
remove these flaws and it doesn't lessen the
emotional impact of the film.
There is also quite a bit of foul language. Amon
uses the f-word regularly (about nine times), there
are two abuses of Christ's name, and mild deity.
It's not the strip scenes or random slaughter that
gives us the greatest feeling of repulsion and
horror. It's the small things. The little girl with
the red coat. Soldiers reassuring the Jews their
luggage will be transported, then taking it into a
building and dumping it in piles to be sorted and
sold. The bin full of pictures... precious images to
those going into the camps, now random, scattered
photographs whose histories will never be known. The
children being thrown into army transports; others
hiding in terrible places around the base. Inside
chimneys, beneath floorboards, even in the latrines.
Dead bodies being exhumed and burned. Portrayal of
the Nazis is incredible; how could mankind ever do
this to anyone? Just to walk up and shoot them for
fun? To take pleasure in their misery? How could the
rest of the world look away for so long while
hundreds of thousands of people were being abused
and murdered? You feel like Schindler... powerless
to do anything, yet determined to show compassion
and kindness. He offers empathy to Helen when she's
the most terrified. He convinces Amon "as a joke" to
hose off the train cars, giving the hot, cramped
occupants some relief. He steps in when the army
wants to take children away from their parents.
It's a powerful movie that reminds us of the nature
of evil, and should be watched by everyone at least
once, when they're fully prepared for the emotional
consequences.
|